Poly Mailing Bags vs Paper Mailing Bags: Which Should You Choose?

When it comes to choosing the right packaging, mailing bags play a crucial role in protecting goods, managing costs, and reflecting your brand. Two of the most popular options - poly mailing bags and paper mailing bags - each offer unique advantages.

At Parcelsend UK, we supply both - and each has a place in the modern mailroom. In this blog, we’ll compare the two side-by-side to help you decide which is right for your products, your budget, and your customers.

Poly Mailing Bags vs Paper Mailing Bags: Which Should You Choose?

🛍️ What Are Poly Mailing Bags?

Poly mailing bags are lightweight, flexible plastic bags commonly used for shipping soft goods such as clothing, accessories, or non-fragile items. They’re waterproof, tear-resistant, and often self-sealing, making them ideal for protecting parcels from the elements during delivery.

Key features:

The key features of poly mailing bags include:

  • Made from polyethylene plastic.
  • Strong and tear-resistant.
  • Lightweight and cost-effective.
  • Moisture-proof.
  • Often available in opaque or grey for privacy.

🛍️ What Are Paper Mailing Bags?

Paper mailing bags are an eco-friendly alternative made from kraft or recycled paper. They’re perfect for companies prioritising sustainability and brand values - especially for lighter, less delicate items. Not only this, but our range of paper mailing bags can also be custom printed.

Key features:

The key features of paper mailing bags include:

  • Made from recyclable or biodegradable paper.
  • More sustainable than plastic alternatives.
  • Suitable for items like clothing, books, and accessories.
  • Often printed with eco-friendly branding.

📏 Let’s Compare: Poly Mailing Bags vs Paper Mailing Bags

Factor Poly Mailing Bags Paper Mailing Bags
Durability ✅ Excellent ✅ Excellent
Water Resistance ✅ Yes ✅ Yes
Sustainability ❌ Not recyclable ✅ Fully recyclable
Brand Image ⚠️ Basic ✅ Premium/Eco
Cost Efficiency ✅ High ⚠️ Moderate

✅ Need Help Choosing?

If you’re shipping in high volumes and want durability, poly mailing bags might be the best choice - especially for budget-conscious e-commerce brands. But if your customers value sustainability, or if you’re a brand with a green ethos, paper mailing bags are a fantastic way to show that you care without compromising on performance for suitable items.

At Parcelsend UK, we stock both poly mailing bags and paper mailing bags in a wide range of sizes and finishes. Still unsure which fits your needs? Get in touch with our team today - we’re happy to help.